 |

NEW YORK VS PARIS
Text: SHAWN BLORE
Illustration: BRUCE ROBERTS
1. Soft Drink/Beer Ratio
I enjoyed a 69-cent Coke from the quasi-upscale Dagostino on 39th and Lexington but didnt risk a US$75 fine for publicly imbibing a $1.20 Budweiser. (Near Washington Square, one creative drinker waved a squeegee to divert cops from his six-pack on ice.) In Paris, six-packs of Coke (2.4 €) and Heineken (4 €) purchased at a Left Bank supermarché carrying 173 varieties of delightfully stinky cheese made a movable (and very liquid) outdoor feast.
In a perfect world, 1:1 or a score of 100; anything lower is sobering.
New York 52.5
Paris 65
FORMULA >
2. Carbohydrate Comparison
I visited H & H, said to have the best bagels on the Upper West Side. But even 10 wood-fired flavours and a slather of cream cheese didnt disguise the fact that these boiled dough rolls are just, well, bread. Theres still nothing like a Parisian croissant (chocolate or plain) for combining rich taste and layered lightness, even when its bought at the obscure Boulangerie St. Paul in Le Marais.
A Parisian croissant is a baseline 100; other carbs must rise to the challenge.
New York 74
Paris 100
FORMULA >
3. Babe and Hunk Index
Parisians are better-looking (as the bumper sticker might say). On the Champs Elysées, nearly one in five people looked like they stepped out of Vogue. I was disappointed to find that Gothamites looked more like cast members from The Sopranos than cute extras from Friends, even outside the Lincoln Center before curtain time. Only in Soho was there a significant concentration of beautiful people.
Summed average of stylish head turners in a crowd of 100.
New York 30.5
Paris 66.5
FORMULA >
4. Street Life Indicator
Pariss Rue de Rivoli had waffles, crepes, mulled wine, cheap jewelry, old books, calculators and saucepans for sale, along with a miniature carousel, riot police and a bum with a sign reading "Jai faim." But with neckties, handbags, T-shirts, umbrellas, watches, baseball hats, U.S. flags, books, magazines and a Shaft-like guy with a "Tell me off for $2" sign, Broadways street scene was unsurpassed. There was nothing to consume on Broadway except soft drinks and candy as the NYPD was conducting a crackdown on unlicensed food vendors (a sure sign of barbarism).
Percentage of goods and attractions available on a busy street or square.
New York 86
Paris 100
FORMULA >
5. Public Order Index
As many as 13 percent of New Yorkers jaywalked in areas like Soho and Times Square. Rising to the challenge, during a quick trip from the Village to Grand Central (3.42 minutes/km), my cabbie indulged in four horn blasts and ran two red lights on Madison. On the Right Bank, one disdainful Parisian in five crossed with nary a glance. The price of this hauteur was snarled traffic and an epic taxi ride (nine minutes/km) between Gare du Nord and the Left Bank. (After my visit, Paris forbade the longtime practice of letting sweet little chiens doo-doo on public sidewalks the beginning of the end?)
Average number of jaywalkers in a crowd of 200 people (low score, low fun factor).
New York 12.1
Paris 21.8
FORMULA >
Conclusion
New York may be the beacon of liberty and America the shining city on a hill, but when it comes to civilized living it appears the New World still has a thing or two to learn from the Old Continent.
New York 255.1
Paris 353.3
-----
STANDINGS:
| Rio | 383.3 |
| Rome | 380.3 |
| Paris | 353.5 |
| Mexico | 346.1 |
| Amsterdam | 343.2 |
| Buenos Aires | 331.8 |
| Zurich | 325.8 |
| Berlin | 325.3 |
| London | 294.1 |
| Mumbai | 289.5 |
| San Francisco | 283.8 |
| Tokyo | 283.8 |
| Hong Kong | 281.5 |
| Moscow | 277.9 |
| Shanghai | 259.2 |
| New York | 255.1 |
| Toronto | 249.1 |
| Washington | 242.0 |
| Montréal | 233.9 |
| Los Angeles | 220.6 |
| Vancouver | 213.1 |
| Chicago | 197.1 |
Next Match : St. Petersburg vs. Havana exclusively at enroutemag.com in December 2004.
Watch for a Civilization Index finale in January 2005. [ ]
|
 |
St. Petersburg vs Havana
Rome vs Buenos Aires
Washington vs Moscow
Mexico vs Tokyo
London vs Mumbai
Chicago vs Berlin
San Francisco vs Shanghai
Toronto vs Zurich
Hong Kong vs Vancouver
Montreal vs Amsterdam
New York vs Paris
Los Angeles vs Rio de Janeiro
STANDINGS
|